AI In Taxation

As a business owner or investor,time is always tight. So it is no surprise that many people now turn to AItools like ChatGPT for quick answers on tax deductions, superannuationcontributions, or structuring ideas. The responses sound confident, arrive instantly,and cost nothing. What could go wrong?

Plenty.

The Australian tax andsuperannuation system is complex, highly fact-specific, and constantlychanging. While AI can be a useful starting point, relying on it for financialdecisions can expose you to audits, penalties, and poor financial outcomes.

Where AI can help -- and where it can't

AI can be helpful for explainingbasic concepts in plain English and prompting the right questions -- forexample, what negative gearing means, the difference between concessional andnon-concessional contributions, or what records you might need to keep.

The problem starts when AI movesfrom explaining concepts to giving advice. Tax and superannuation outcomesdepend on your specific facts: income levels, structure, age, residency status,assets, timing, and future plans. AI does not know these details unless youprovide them -- and you generally should not. Even then, it cannot applyjudgement or balance competing risks the way an experienced adviser can.

The accuracy risk: confident, but wrong

AI tools are known to produceresponses that sound authoritative but are incorrect or incomplete. Inpractice, this can mean:

-     Claiming deductions that do not apply to yourcircumstances

-     Miscalculating capital gains tax or ignoring integrityrules

-     Suggesting super strategies that breach contributioncaps or eligibility rules

-     Quoting legislation, cases, rulings, or concessionsthat do not exist or are out of date

A recent decision highlights howquickly this can go wrong. In Smith and Commissioner of Taxation [2026] ARTA25, the Tribunal criticised the use of non-existent or irrelevant authoritiesand noted the burden this places on proceedings when material is not properlyverified.

ATO scrutiny is increasing, not decreasing

The ATO is not anti-AI -- theyuse advanced analytics internally -- but their public guidance is clear:misinformation, including AI-generated content, can be false, inaccurate,incomplete, or outdated. If something is wrong in your return, the ATO will generallyamend it, charge interest, and may apply penalties -- even if the mistake camefrom an AI tool rather than from intent.

We are seeing this most oftenwith work-from-home claims, property deductions, and SMSF compliance.

Superannuation: high stakes, little margin for error

Super is an area where AI advicecan be particularly dangerous. SMSFs operate under strict rules and AI oftenmisses eligibility tests, timing requirements, and investment restrictions. Theresult can be non-compliance, forced unwinding of transactions, and penaltiesrunning into thousands of dollars.

Data security and privacy

There is also a practical riskthat many people overlook: entering personal or financial information into AIplatforms. Once data is entered, you lose control over how it is stored orused. This creates privacy and fraud risks that are simply not worth taking.

The bottom line

AI can be a helpful assistant,but it is not your accountant. Use it to understand concepts and generatequestions -- then get professional advice before you act. It almost alwayscosts less to clarify upfront than to fix an ATO problem later.

If you have questions about yourtax or super position, contact our team for reliable, tailored advice.

‍